ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦
ããå§åï¼ è·¯å¾·ç»´å¸Â·çº¦ç夫·约翰·维ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦
ããåºçï¼ 1889å¹´4æ26æ¥ (奥å°å©ç»´ä¹çº³)
ããéä¸ï¼ 1951å¹´4æ29æ¥ (è±å½åæ¡¥)
ããå¦æ´¾/æµæ´¾ï¼ åæå²å¦, è¯è¨å²å¦
ãã主è¦é¢åï¼ å½¢èä¸å¦, 认è¯è®º, é»è¾å¦, è¯è¨å²å¦, æ°å¦å²å¦
ããèåææ³ï¼ è¯è¨çå¾è±¡è®º, âä¸å¯è¯´â, âæä¹å³ä½¿ç¨â, è¯è¨æ¸¸æ, 家æç¸ä¼¼, âç§äººè¯è¨â论è¯, ç活形å¼
ããåå½±åäºï¼ ç¥å
æ, åæ¬å, å¼é·æ ¼, ç½ç´ , G.E.æ©å°, éå®æ ¼, æå§å¡, æ¯ææ³
ããæ½å½±åäºï¼ ç½ç´ , æ¯ç¹å³æ£®, å
éæ®å
, å¡å°, æ®ç¹å, æ´ç»´æ£®, 达米ç¹, å¯Â·èµç¹, 丹å
ç¹, ç½è, å®æ¯åº·å§, æå§å¡, è±ç¹, ç®ç¹Â·æµ·å
, 麦å
éå¨å°, å¥å é¡¿, éå°å¨å¥, 麦å
é, æ´èå¾·, æ¯åç¹, å奥å¡å¾·
ãã路德维å¸Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼Ludwig Wittgensteinï¼é¦æ¸¯åå°æ¹¾è¯ä½ç»´æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼1889å¹´4æ26æ¥ï¼1951å¹´4æ29æ¥ï¼ï¼åºçäºå¥¥å°å©ï¼åå
¥è±å½ç±ãå²å¦å®¶ãæ°çé»è¾å¦å®¶ãè¯è¨å²å¦çå¥ åºäººï¼20ä¸çºªææå½±åçå²å¦å®¶ä¹ä¸ã
ããçå¹³
ãã路德维å¸Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦äº1889å¹´4æ26æ¥åºçäºå¥¥åå¸å½çç»´ä¹çº³ï¼ç¶äº²å¡å°Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦æ¯æ¬§æ´²é¢éå·¥ä¸å·¨å¤´ï¼æ¯äº²è±å¥¥æ³¢è¿ªå
ï¼åè¶å
å¤ç¥ç¶ä¹å§è¡¨å¦¹ï¼æ¯é¶è¡å®¶ç女å¿ã路德维å¸å¨å
«ä¸ªå女ä¸æè¡æå°ï¼æç¾çç¹å¤ªè¡ç»ï¼äºçº³ç²¹å并奥å°å©å转å
¥è±å½ç±ã
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä¸å¸ç¹å1903å¹´äºæè¨çä¸æä¸å¦ãæç
§å½æ¶æ¯ä¾ï¼æç
§çä½ç½®æ ¹æ®æ绩å®æãæ绩è¶å¥½çå¦çè¶å¾åæåå¨è·èå¸è¶è¿çä½ç½®ï¼æ绩差çååä¹ã
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä¸å¸ç¹å1903å¹´äºæè¨çä¸æä¸å¦ã
ããæç
§å½æ¶æ¯ä¾ï¼æç
§çä½ç½®æ ¹æ®æ绩å®æãæ绩è¶å¥½çå¦çè¶å¾åæåå¨è·èå¸è¶è¿çä½ç½®ï¼æ绩差çååä¹ã
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦èªå¹¼è·éå
å§å¨å®¶éæ¥åæè²ï¼ç¶è家åºæè²çç»æå´æ æ³ä½¿å
¶è¾¾å°æ£è§é«ä¸çæ¥çº³æ åãç´å°1903å¹´å¨éè¿å
¥å¦èè¯ååå¾æè¨çä¸æ以ææ¯è称çä¸å¦å¦ä¹ ï¼ä¸é¿é夫·å¸ç¹ååå¦[2]ï¼ä¸è¿å°æªæç¡®å¿çè¯æ®è¡¨æè¿ä¸¤ä½éè¦äººç©æè¿ä»»ä½æ·±å
¥ç交å¾ãåä¸äºä¼å¤§äººç©ä¸æ ·ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¨ä¸å¦çæ绩并ä¸å¥½ï¼å¤§é½å¤äºä¸ä¸æ°´å¹³[1]ï¼å¨åº¦è¿äºä¸å¹´çä¸æå¿«åï¼æ´å¸¦çé«èçè½è´¥ç¦»å¼äºè¿éãå°å¹´è·¯å¾·ç»´å¸ç±å¥½æºæ¢°ä¸ææ¯ï¼åå²æ¶å°±å¶åºè¿ä¸å°ç®åå®ç¨çç¼çº«æºãå
¶æåçå¿åå¨äºç©çå¦ï¼æ¾ç»æ¸´æå¸ä»èåç©çå¦å®¶ç»å°è¨æ¼ï¼ç¶èï¼åè
äº1906å¹´èªæï¼ä½¿å¾ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦çå¸ææ¯äºä¸æ¦ãéåç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦åç«å¿æ为ä¸åå·¥ç¨å¸ã1906å¹´ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦åå¾ææå¦ä¹ æºæ¢°å·¥ç¨ã1908å¹´ï¼è¿å
¥è±å½æ¼å½»æ¯ç¹ç»´å¤å©äºå¤§å¦æ»è¯»èªç©ºå·¥ç¨ç©ºæ°å¨åå¦å¦ä½ãæé´ï¼ä¸ºäºå½»åºææ¸
èºæ桨çåçï¼åæ¶åºäºå¯¹æ°å¦åºç¡çå
´è¶£ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦é
读äºä¼¯ç¹å
°Â·ç½ç´ ä¸æç¹æµ·ååçãæ°å¦åçã以åæç¹æ´å¸Â·å¼é·æ ¼çãç®æ¯åºç¡ããå¨1911å¹´å¤å¤©æ访äºå¼é·æ ¼åï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¬ä»äºè¿ä½é»è¾å¦å®¶çæ¨èï¼åå¾è±å½å桥大å¦ä¸ä¸å¦é¢é®å¦äºç½ç´ é¨ä¸ï¼åæ为è±å½å²å¦å®¶ç½ç´ çå¦çå
¼å¥½åï¼ç½ç´ 称è¿åºç¸è¯æ¯ä»ä¸çä¸âæ令人å
´å¥çæºæ
§æ¢é©ä¹ä¸âã第ä¸æ¬¡ä¸ç大æå¼å§åæ¬å¯å
æå
µå½¹çç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä½ä¸ºå¿æ¿å
µç§¯æå
¥ä¼ï¼å¨æåºä¸å®æäºæ å¿æè°å²å¦çè¯è¨å¦è½¬åçãé»è¾å²å¦è®ºã(è±æçï¼Tractatus Logico - Philosophicusï¼å¾·æçï¼Logische - Philosophische Abhandlung)çå稿ããé»è¾å²å¦è®ºãåä»è®¤ä¸ºæè°çå²å¦é®é¢å·²è¢«è§£å³ï¼äºæ¯æçè´µæå¼çç忱åå¾å¥¥å°å©åé¨å±±åºï¼æå
¥æ ¼å¾å
å°å¡å¯¼ç奥å°å©å¦æ ¡æ¹é©è¿å¨ï¼æ为ä¸åå°å¦æå¸ãæççæ³ä¸»ä¹è¿½æ±çç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¨è¿éè¿çè¦è¡å§è¬ççæ´»ï¼å¯¹å¦çä¹å
满äºçæ
ï¼ç¶èå´è¢«æ æ³ç解ç家é¿ä»¬è§ä¸ºâç¯çç家ä¼âï¼ä»ä»¬æç»äºè¿ä¸ªå¤æªå®¶ä¼æåºçæ¶å
Ȍ
¶ä¸ä¸ä¸ªæ两个å¦ççè¦æ±ã1926å¹´ï¼è¢«è¯ææ»æ¯ä¸æå¹´äººæ ¼æ ¼ä¸å
¥çç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ç¦»å¼äºâç²ä¿æè ¢çåé¨åæ°âï¼ç»æäºä¹¡ææå¸çèä½ã
ããä½å°å¦æå¸â失败âä¹åç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å
æ¯å¨ä¸ä¸ªä¿®éé¢éä½è¿çæ¶é´çåä¸å©æï¼åæ¥å
¶å§çæ ¼ä¸½ç¹ç±äºæ
å¿ä»çç²¾ç¥ç¶æè设æ³è¦æ±å
¶åå©è®¾è®¡å¹¶è´è´£å»ºé äºèªå·±çä¸å¤å®
第ãè¿ä¸ªåæ¥æ¾è¢«ç¨ä½ä¿å å©äºä½¿é¦ç建çç©ä½¿ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦è·å¾äºå»ºçå¸ç身份ã1927å¹´ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ç»è¯äºå¥ãé»è¾å²å¦è®ºã为åè¬çâç»´ä¹çº³å°ç»âæå并åºéåä¸ä¸äºæ´»å¨ï¼ä¸ç³éå
ãéæ¯æ¼çæåæè¿äº¤å¾ï¼ç¶èç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦æç»å å
¥ä»ä»¬çååã1928å¹´æ¥å¨å¬äºæ°å¦å®¶å¸å³ç»´å°å¨ç»´ä¹çº³æå
³âæ°å¦ãç§å¦åè¯è¨âçä¸æ¬¡è®²æ¼åï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦éæ°èåäºå¼ºççå²å¦æ¢ç´¢çå
´è¶£ã1929å¹´ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦éè¿åæ¡¥ï¼ä»¥ãé»è¾å²å¦è®ºãä½ä¸ºè®ºæéè¿äºç±ç½ç´ åG.E.æ©å°ä¸»æè¯å®¡çå士ç辩åï¼çå¨ä¸ä¸å¦é¢ææå²å¦ï¼å¹¶äº1939å¹´æ¥æ¿æ©å°æ为å²å¦ææã1947å¹´ï¼åä¿¡âå²å¦ææâæ¯âä¸ä»½èåçå·¥ä½âçç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä»åæ¡¥è¾èï¼ä»¥ä¸å¿æèãåä½ã
ãã1951å¹´4æ29æ¥ï¼èº«æ£ååè
ºççç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¨å¥½åæ¯ä¸(Edward Bevan)å»ç家ä¸ä¸ä¸é¿è¾ãå»ä¸åç±å¼åå®æ¯åº·å§(Elizabeth Anscombe)åéæ¯(Rush Rhees)åºçäºè¢«è®¤ä¸ºæ¯å¼å¯¼äºè¯è¨å²å¦æ°çèµ°åçãå²å¦ç 究ã(è±æçï¼Philosophical Investigationsï¼å¾·æçï¼Philosophische Untersuchungen)ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦çä¸çæå¯ä¼ å¥è²å½©ï¼è¢«ç½ç´ 称为â天æ人ç©çæå®ç¾èä¾âï¼çæ
ãæ·±å»ã认çã纯æ£ãåºç±»æèã[2]
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å
·ææ为深åçæåç´ å
»ï¼å¯¹äººç±»çåæ¬è´¨æçæ·±å»çæç¥[3]ãæ©å¹´ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å®¶ææçæµåçèºæ¯æåæ°å´ï¼ç¶äº²å¡å°•ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦æ¯é¿æçèºæ¯æå©åï¼åæå§æ¯ã马åçæ¯è¿ä¸ªè¢«é³ä¹å
满ç家åºéç常客ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å®¶ææåä¸é³ä¹å¤©èµä¸ç®çªåºç路德维å¸å
¶å簧管æ¼å¥ä¹å¾æé 诣ï¼åæ ·ï¼è¢«è®¤ä¸ºæ¯æ书é¢è¡¨è¾¾éç¢çç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦çæç¬å´ä¹ååç²¾æ¹ãå¦å¤ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦åååç±å¥¥å°å©æèºè¯è®ºå®¶å¡å°Â·å
å³æ¯(Karl Kraus)çèä½ãç¶èâä¸å¹¸âå´å¾æ©å°±ä¸è¿ä½å²å¦å®¶å¦å½±éå½¢ï¼å¤ç¬åæéå
满äºç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦çä¸çãæ®å
¶ä¼ è®°ä½è
å¨å»Â·å·´ç¹å©(William Warren Bartley)èè¯ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å®¶æçå
å¼äºäººéï¼å
æ¬è·¯å¾·ç»´å¸Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦æ¬äººå
±æä¸åæ¯åæ§æè
ï¼è¿å
¶ä¸ç两个å
é¿æ±æ¯åé²é夫æ©å¹´åå«èªæï¼æ¤åç¶äº²å¡å°Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦è½ç¶æ¾ç¼äºå¯¹å女们ç严åï¼é年路德维å¸å´ä»ç¶å¸¸å¸¸æ令ç½ç´ æ
å¿çèªæå¾åï¼æ®ç§°å
¶æ¬äººåå ä¸æå°±æ¯ä¸ºäºâä½é¢å°èªæâãä»çå¦ä¸ä¸ªå
é¿åºç¹Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¨æåºä¸è¢«ä¿åèªæï¼å¨æäºé幸åä½è´æ®çæåä¸ä½å
é¿ï¼ä¿ç½Â·ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼æ¯èåçåèé¢ç´å®¶ã
ãã[ç¼è¾] å²å¦ç®ä»
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦æ¯è¯è¨å¦æ´¾(大约ç¸å½äºåæå²å¦)ç主è¦ä»£è¡¨äººç©ãä»ææ³çæåæºæ³ä¸»è¦æ¥èªå¼é·æ ¼çç°ä»£é»è¾å¦ææãç½ç´ ä¸æç¹æµ·åçãæ°å¦åçãåG.E.æ©å°çã伦çå¦åçããä»çå²å¦ä¸»è¦ç 究çæ¯è¯è¨ï¼ä»æ³æ示å½äººä»¬äº¤æµæ¶ï¼è¡¨è¾¾èªå·±çæ¶åå°åçäºä»ä¹ãä»ä¸»å¼ å²å¦çæ¬è´¨å°±æ¯è¯è¨ãè¯è¨æ¯äººç±»ææ³ç表达ï¼æ¯æ´ä¸ªææçåºç¡ï¼å²å¦çæ¬è´¨åªè½å¨è¯è¨ä¸å¯»æ¾ãä»æ¶è§£äºä¼ ç»å½¢èä¸å¦çå¯ä¸æ¬è´¨ï¼ä¸ºå²å¦æ¾å°äºæ°çåå±æ¹åãä»ç主è¦èä½ãé»è¾å²å¦è®ºãåãå²å¦ç 究ãåå«ä»£è¡¨äºæ¨ªè´¯å
¶ä¸ççå²å¦éè·¯ç两个äºä¸ºå¯¹æ¯çé¶æ®µãåè
主è¦æ¯è§£æï¼è®©å²å¦æ为è¯è¨å¦é®é¢ï¼å²å¦å¿
é¡»ç´é¢è¯è¨ï¼âå¡æ¯è½å¤è¯´çäºæ
ï¼é½è½å¤è¯´æ¸
æ¥ï¼èå¡æ¯ä¸è½è¯´çäºæ
ï¼å°±åºè¯¥æ²é»â[4]ï¼å²å¦æ éæ¯æé®é¢è®²æ¸
æ¥ãåè
åæå²å¦åå½å²å¦ï¼å¨è§£æä¹åæ¯å»ºæï¼åé ä¸å¥ä¸¥æ ¼çå¯ä»¥è¡¨è¿°å²å¦çè¯è¨æ¯ä¸å¯è½çï¼å 为æ¥å¸¸çæ´»çè¯è¨æ¯ççä¸æ¯çï¼è¿æ¯å²å¦çåºç¡åæºæ³ï¼æ以å²å¦çæ¬è´¨åºè¯¥å¨æ¥å¸¸ç活解å³ï¼å¨â游æâä¸ç解游æã
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä»çååæææ³è½¬åå¾å¤§[3]ï¼ä»å¨ãå²å¦ç 究ãåºè¨ä¸è¯´æåæèä½ç¯äºä¸¥éçé误ï¼å½ç¶ï¼ä»ä¹è¯´è¿è¦æååæèä½å¯¹æ¯ï¼ä»¥åæèä½ä½ä¸ºèæ¯æ¥ç解åæå²å¦ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ææ³è½¬åæ¥æºäºä»èªå·±çé¿æçç¬ç«æè以åä»çèå¸ææåç帮å©ãä»çç¬ç«æèç¦ç¹å¨äºå¦ä½æ为ä¸ä¸ªâå½¢èä¸å¦çèªæâï¼ä¸ä¸ªå¯ä¸ä¸çè¿è¡ä¸æä¿¡æ¯äº¤æµçèªæãä»çèå¸ææåï¼å¦ç»æµå¦å®¶ç®è¶ç½Â·æ¯ææ³[5]å使ä»æ¥è§¦å°è¯è¨ç¤¾ä¼æ§çä¸é¢ï¼ä»ä»¬çè§ç¹å¯¹äºçº¯æ£å®éçé»è¾ä¸çæ¯ä¸ç§å²å»ï¼å èä¹æå©äºç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦èµ°åºçº¯åçé»è¾ä¸çï¼é¢åå§é¹çæ¥å¸¸è¯è¨äº¤æµä¸çã
ããèä½
ãã* é»è¾å²å¦è®º(åä½ãåç论ã)ï¼å¼ ç³åº è¯ï¼éå¯ä¼ æ ¡
ãã* å²å¦ç 究ï¼éåæ è¯ï¼ä¸æµ·ä¸çºªåºçéå¢ï¼2001
ãã* 论确å®æ§ï¼å¼ éè¨ è¯ï¼å¹¿è¥¿å¸è大å¦åºç社
ãã* æåä¸ä»·å¼
ãã* èç®ä¹¦åæ£ç®ä¹¦
ãã* å
³äºæ°å¦åºç¡çè¯è®º
ãã* å²å¦è¯æ³¨
ãã* å²å¦è¯æ³
ãã* ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å桥讲æ¼é
ãã* èç®ä¹¦
ãã* ä¸ç§å²å¦çèå¯
ãã* 论æ°å¦çåºç¡
ãã* å¿çå¦å²å¦è¯è®º
ãã* æè¯
ãã* 纸æ¡é
ãã* å
³äºé¢è²çè¯è®º
ãã* å
³äºä¼¦çå¦ç讲æ¼ä»¥åå
¶ä»
ãã* 论è²å½©
ãã* å¿çå¦å²å¦æåèä½
ããç 究æç®
ããå¤æåè
ãã* 马å°åº·å§ï¼ãåå¿ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ã(Norman Malcolm, Ludwig Wittgenstein: A Memoir)ï¼ææ¥æ¥¼ãè´ºç»ç² è¯ï¼åå¡å°ä¹¦é¦ï¼1984
ãã* è·ç®å°æ£®ï¼ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å²å¦å¯¼è®ºã(C.A.Van Pearson, Ludwig Wittgenstein: An Introduction to His philosophy)ï¼åä¸ã谢维å è¯ï¼åå·äººæ°åºç社ï¼1988
ãã* è¾è¶å°ï¼ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ãï¼éæ°¸å®ã许æ¯
å è¯ï¼ä¸å½ç¤¾ä¼ç§å¦åºç社ï¼1989
ãã* å¨å»Â·å·´ç¹å©ï¼ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä¼ ãï¼æ丽ç è¯ï¼ä¸æ¹åºçä¸å¿ï¼2000
ãã* ç®å°æ¯ï¼ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ãï¼çæå
µ çè¯ï¼æä»åºç社ï¼2000
ããä¸æåè
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å²å¦è¿°è¯ãï¼èçå
èï¼ ä¸è书åºï¼1982
ãã* ã寻æ¾å®¶åââå¤ç»´è§éä¸çç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦è¯è¨å²å¦ãï¼å°å¿è± èï¼äººæ°åºç社 1992
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å²å¦ä¹è·¯ãï¼é©æå èï¼äºå大å¦åºç社ï¼1996ï¼å°æ¹¾ï¼1994
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼ä¸ç§åå²å¦çæåãï¼æ±æ¡ èï¼ç¤¾ç§æç®åºç社ï¼1996ï¼1998ï¼2002
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä¼ ãï¼æ±æ¡ èï¼æ²³å人æ°åºç社ï¼1997
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ãï¼æ±æ¡ èï¼æ¹åæè²åºç社ï¼1999
ãã* ãèµ°åºè¯è¨ç迷宫ï¼åæç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å²å¦æ¦è¿°ãï¼çæå èï¼ç¤¾ç§æç®åºç社ï¼1999
ãã* ããé»è¾å²å¦è®ºãç 究ãï¼é©æå èï¼åå¡å°ä¹¦é¦ï¼2000
ãã* ããé»è¾å²å¦è®ºã导读ãï¼æ±æ¡ èï¼åå·æè²åºç社ï¼2002
ãã* âç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦âï¼ã西æ¹èåå²å¦å®¶è¯ä¼ ã(ç»ç¼ä¸å·)ï¼å¾åæ¸ èï¼å±±ä¸äººæ°åºç社ï¼1988
ãã* ãâå¥ç½å°¼å¼âçé©å½ãï¼å¾åæ¸ èï¼ä¸æµ·ä¸è书åºï¼1994
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼ èµ°åºè¯è¨å笼ãï¼å¼ å¦å¹¿ ç¼èï¼æ ¹æ®Ray Monk è Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty of Geniusï¼è¾½æµ·åºç社ï¼1999
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ½å¦ãï¼èµµæ¦å èï¼é¦æ¸¯ï¼1987
ãã* ãç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å²å¦ââä»çåæå²å¦çè¯ éï¼æ¹å¤åæ¢ç´¢ãï¼åç¦å¢ èï¼å°æ¹¾ï¼1987
ãã* ãå²å¦åæç天æââç»´æ ¹æ¯å¦ãï¼éè£æ³¢ èï¼å°æ¹¾ï¼1982
ãã* ãç»´æ ¹æ¯å¦ãï¼éè£æ³¢ æ°ï¼ æ³¢å°æ£® åèï¼å°æ¹¾ï¼1982
ããè¯å½
ãã* ç½ç´ ï¼ä½ å°åºå¨æèä»ä¹ï¼é»è¾ï¼è¿æ¯èªå·±ç罪ï¼
ããç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼ä¸¤è
[6]ã
ãã* ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦å¨å
¶å士论æç辩ä¼ä¸å¯¹ç½ç´ ä¸æ©å°è¯´ï¼å«æ
å¿ï¼æç¥éä½ ä»¬æ°¸è¿ä¹æä¸äºæå¨è¯´ä»ä¹ã
ãã* ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦è¯´ï¼âä½ è¯¯è§£æçææäºï¼ç½ç´ ãä½ æ»æ¯è¯¯è§£æãâ
ããç½ç´ 说ï¼âä½ æ··æ·äºé®é¢ï¼ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼ä½ æ»æ¯æé®é¢è¶æè¶ç³æ¶ãâ
ãã* ç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ä¸¾èµ·æ¨ç«æ£æåæ³¢æ®ï¼âè¯·ä½ ç»åºä¸ä¸ªçæ£çéå¾·é®é¢ï¼â
ããæ³¢æ®ååç¸è®¥ï¼â请ä¸è¦ç¨æ¨ç«æ£å¨èä¸ä¸ªåå°é请ç客人ï¼â
ããç½ç´ ï¼âç»´ç¹æ ¹æ¯å¦ï¼ç«å»æ¾ä¸æ¨ç«æ£ï¼â
ãã* ä¸ä¸ªäººä¸ç¯å¢æ ¼æ ¼ä¸å
¥çæ¶åï¼ä»çä¸åçæºå°±å¤±å»äºåºæçæ£å¸¸ï¼æ¾åºåç§ç
æãåªæ让ä»åå½æ¬æ§ï¼æä¼æè¯å¥½çç»æï¼ä½¿ä¸åæ¾åºæ£å¸¸ã
ãã* å²å¦å®¶å¤çä¸ä¸ªé®é¢å¦åæ²»çä¸ä¸ªç¾ç
ã
ãã* å²å¦æ¯é对åå©æ们çè¯è¨æ¥èææ们çæºæ§æåçæäºã[7]
ãã* å²å¦çç»ææ¯æ们åç°äºæ们ççæºå¨å²æè¯è¨ççéæ¶æçä¸çè¿ååç±æ¤å¼èµ·çç´æ¥äºå½çè¡è¯´ãèæ£æ¯è¿äºè¿å使æ们çå°äºè¿ç§åç°çä»·å¼ã
ãã* é·å
¥å²å¦å°å¢å°±åè¿æ ·ä¸ç§æ
åµï¼ä¸ä¸ªäººå¨æ¿é´éæ³è¦åºå»ï¼å´åä¸ç¥éæä¹åãæ³ä»çªè·³æ·åºå»ï¼å¯æ¯çªæ·å¤ªå°ï¼è¯çä»çå±ç¬åºå»ï¼å¯æ¯çå±å¤ªé«ãç¶èåªè¦ä¸è½¬è¿èº«æ¥ï¼ä»å°±ä¼åç°ï¼æ¿é¨ä¸ç´æ¯å¼ççï¼
ãã* ä»ä¹æ¯å²å¦ï¼ââå°±æ¯ç»èèæåºéåºæèç¶çéè·¯ã
ãã* 使æ们æå°è¿·è«çæ··ä¹±ï¼äº§çäºè¯è¨åæºå¨ç©ºé²çæ¶åï¼èä¸æ¯å®æ£å¸¸å·¥ä½çæ¶åã
ãã* çæ£çåç°æ¯ï¼å½ææ³æå²å¦æ¶ä½¿æè½å¤åæ¢è¿æ ·åã
ãã* å²å¦åªæ¯æä¸åæå¨æ们é¢åï¼å®æ¢ä¸è§£éä»ä¹ï¼ä¹ä¸æ¨æ¼ä»ä¹ãâå 为ä¸åé½å·²å
¬å¼å°æå¨é£éäºï¼æ²¡æä»ä¹è¦è§£éçã
ãã* å²å¦ç对象æ¯å¯¹ææ³çé»è¾éæãå²å¦ä¸æ¯ä¸ç§ç论èæ¯ä¸ç§æ´»å¨
ãã* ä¸è¦æ³ï¼èè¦çï¼
ãã* å¡è½å¤è¯´çï¼é½è½å¤è¯´æ¸
æ¥ï¼å¡ä¸è½è°è®ºçï¼å°±åºè¯¥ä¿ææ²é»ã
ãã* å¦æä½ ä»¬ä»¥ä¸ºææ¯ä¸ªèå¤ç·ï¼é£å°±éäºï¼[8]
ãã* åè¯ä»ä»¬ï¼æ度è¿äºç¾å¥½çä¸çã[9]
ããåèä¸æ³¨é
ãã1. â é©æå
ãã2. â Russell: He was perhaps the most perfect example I have ever known of genius as traditionally conceived, passionate, profound, intense and dominating
ãã3. â éåæ
ãã4. â è±è¯ï¼Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent./ What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence. å¾·è¯ï¼Wovon man nicht sprechen kann, darueber muss man schweigen
ãã5. â Piero Sraffa
ãã6. â Both
ãã7. â Philosophie ist ein Kampf gegen die Verhexung unsres Verstandes durch die Mittel unserer Sprache.
ãã8. â "If you think I'm an old spinster â think again!"
ãã9. â "Tell them I've had a wonderful life."
ãã* è¯è¨å²å¦
ãã* ãé»è¾å²å¦è®ºã
ãã* ãå²å¦ç 究ã
ãã* çå¼è¡¨
ãã* 伯ç¹å
°Â·ç½ç´
ãã* ç»´ä¹çº³å°ç»
åèèµæï¼ç¾åº¦ç¾ç§